Room 2 screen reader tip: this page has six articles, each with a "Read"
control. Navigate by buttons to move between them — but you will only
find five. The sixth article's control was built as a plain element, not
a real button, so it is never announced and the keyboard cannot reach
it. Find that article to reveal your clue.
Challenge Room 2
The Reading Room
Six articles. Five real buttons.
One impostor.
Hint: All six "Read" controls look identical. But only
five are real buttons — the sixth is a styled
<div> pretending to be one. The keyboard can reach all
of them, however one will be read out differently. Enable VoiceOver
(Cmd+F5 on Mac) or NVDA on Windows, navigate by buttons (B
in browse mode), and notice that one article button is read out
differently.
I can’t work this out — show me how
How to solve it
Turn on a screen reader: VoiceOver on a Mac (Cmd+F5), or NVDA (free) or Narrator (Ctrl+Win+Enter) on Windows.
Jump between the buttons on the page. In NVDA, press B. In VoiceOver, open the Rotor (Control+Option+U) and use the arrow keys to choose Form Controls.
You’ll hear five “Read the article… button” announcements. The sixth article, Built for Everyone, never comes up — its control isn’t a real button.
That’s the impostor. Turn off the screen reader and click the Read control under Built for Everyone with your mouse.
No screen reader? Try reaching that last “Read” control with Tab and pressing Enter — nothing happens. Then click it with your mouse.
Why this matters for students
To a sighted mouse user, all six controls are identical. To a student using a screen reader, the sixth one barely exists — it isn’t announced as a button and can’t be pressed from the keyboard. They’d never open that article, and might not even know they’d missed it. This happens whenever something is built to look like a button without actually being one.
Still stuck? Just show me the clue
Your Room 2 clue is SEMANTIC. Note it down for the final code.
This Month's Articles
page 12
The Four-Day Week, One Year On
Companies that cut a day report happier staff and steadier output.
The numbers behind the trial.
page 24
Cooking With What's Left
How a generation of home cooks learned to turn leftovers and odd
ends into something worth the table.
page 31
The Quiet Return of the Library
Once written off, local libraries are busier than ever. A look at
why people keep coming back.
page 40
Why We Still Love Vinyl
Records outsell CDs again. Collectors and first-timers explain the
pull of the physical.
page 52
Notes From a Car-Free City
One month, no cars in the center. Residents on what changed, for
better and worse.
page 63
Built for Everyone
What it really takes to design a product that works for every
reader — not just most of them.
Read
📰
You Found the Impostor
That last "Read" control looked exactly like the other five —
same style, same label. But it was a <div>, not a
<button>. A mouse user can't tell the difference, but
to someone who cannot rely on their vision, this labeling makes all
the difference in being able to interact with the page or not.
Identical on screen, completely different underneath. That's why
semantic HTML matters.
Your Room 2 clueSEMANTIC
Note it down, then continue to the next room — or head back to
the Lab to choose your own path.